Here's the unblock request:
QUOTE
Request reason: "My comment in the talk page was to the point and factually correct. Otherwise why was the article stubbed and protected if I was not correct in my assertion that it was wholly an attack on Judd Bagley? Also why is Weiss carrying on using yet another sockpuppet "Samiharris" in order to delete other people's comments which is a violation of WP:CIVIL amongst other things? Does Fred Bauder know that Weiss is carrying on with the sockpuppetry after having told Weiss to stop?
Secondly, and more to the point, David Gerard has yet to demonstrate that this IP address is being used by Judd Bagley or is a "zombie PC" or "open proxy" Can we have a demonstration of Gerard's assertion or will we have to conclude that Gerard just abuses his admin rights when he doesn't get his own way on promoting attack BLPs?
Let's see the evidence.
Or alternatively, can Wikimedia come clean and just admit that any criticism of Gary Weiss is justification for immediate banning without so much as reference to any other bylaw of Wikipedia?"
Secondly, and more to the point, David Gerard has yet to demonstrate that this IP address is being used by Judd Bagley or is a "zombie PC" or "open proxy" Can we have a demonstration of Gerard's assertion or will we have to conclude that Gerard just abuses his admin rights when he doesn't get his own way on promoting attack BLPs?
Let's see the evidence.
Or alternatively, can Wikimedia come clean and just admit that any criticism of Gary Weiss is justification for immediate banning without so much as reference to any other bylaw of Wikipedia?"
and the reply:
QUOTE
Decline reason: "Even if this IP is not an open proxy, it seems quite clear to me from your comments here that you are at least affiliated in some way with Bagley, and your personal attacks on other editors seem to only confirm that you are not here to contribute constructively. — krimpet⟲ 19:43, 15 September 2007 (UTC)"
So the reason doesn't actually matter because I am somehow "affiliated in some way with Bagley" (and I haven't even seen the ring). It matters not what that "affilation" may be, only that it can be asserted without proof.
Pathetic.
Franz Kafka never had a nightmare bad enough to compare with Wikipedia.