QUOTE(Adam Smithee @ Tue 9th September 2008, 12:56pm)
![*](style_images/brack/post_snapback.gif)
QUOTE(thekohser @ Tue 9th September 2008, 3:15pm)
![*](style_images/brack/post_snapback.gif)
So, be honest... Is it that the article is that poorly done, or is it that the author is such a hot potato to be worth it?
Well for starters, personally I wouldn't do it simply because an admin account suddenly logging on after dormancy to post that article would mean that it would be ridiculously easy to tie this account to my mostly unused Wikipedia account. That is something I'm not overly interested in doing at this time. Besides, you and I both know that the article would be dumped as a proxy posting for a banned user and the user posting it would be subjected to the usual castigation for being a sock/meat puppet.
On strictly a content level, I've never really been a huge fan of most corporate articles unless it can be reasonably demonstrated that it is a fairly widely known and recognizable business, but that is just me. Besides, what has National Fuel Gas Company ever done to you Greg that you want to open them up to having an article that, if kept on Wikipedia, would most likely be subject to lots of unfounded and poorly sourced criticism? If I owned a company, having a Wikipedia article would be a nightmare given the uneven response given to many complaints about biased coverage. Unless you know how to find the handful of admins who actually will listen to a complaint, it's a complete headache being listed there.
Well put. But, we also have to think about That Kid In Africa, writing their mid-term paper on American natural gas companies, and Jimbo encourages Wikipedia as a "first step" reference resource. What is the Kid to do if there's no article about NFG?
Disclaimer: I have no past or current interaction with National Fuel Gas. Just many moons ago, I noted that it was absent from Wikipedia, despite being a Fortune 1000 (#785) operation, so I thought Wikipedia might like a short article with which to get started helping African Kids.