Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Stealthy Gotcha!-Type DYKs on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict
> Wikimedia Discussion > General Discussion
pedrito
So what's the newest and coolest in POV-pusing on Wikipedia?

Dump a badly-written hatchet job on your favourite subject (e.g. the Israeli-Palestinian conflict), wait three days and post a DYK linking it.

With a bit of luck and balls, your pet-POV will be splashed on Mainpage before you know it! If you cop some flack, just call some friends in for backup on the ensuing discussion.

Cheers,
Pedrito
A Horse With No Name
QUOTE(pedrito @ Tue 19th May 2009, 3:22am) *

So what's the newest and coolest in POV-pusing on Wikipedia?

Dump a badly-written hatchet job on your favourite subject (e.g. the Israeli-Palestinian conflict), wait three days and post a DYK linking it.

With a bit of luck and balls, your pet-POV will be splashed on Mainpage before you know it! If you cop some flack, just call some friends in for backup on the ensuing discussion.

Cheers,
Pedrito


Did you know...

*...DYK award templates are 10 times the size of an FA icon but carry ten times less value?
*...that you'll-scratch-my-back-I'll-scratch-yours scheming and rewarding is prevalent among long-time DYK contributors and "judges"?
*...that some DYK addicts need to get a life -- particularly Daniel Case, who seems obsessed with ripping off National Register of Historic Places paperwork in order to create a staggering volume of articles on obscure upstate New York shacks?
*...that people actually spend months planning for the April Fool's Day DYK page, which is inevitably the least amusing line-up of articles imaginable?
*...that no one in the real world gives a flying fuck about the trivia line-up on DYK?
Somey
QUOTE(A Horse With No Name @ Tue 19th May 2009, 7:57am) *
...DYK award templates are 10 times the size of an FA icon but carry ten times less value?

That depends on what constitutes "value," doesn't it? AFAIK, Google doesn't differentiate much between a DYK link and the FA link from the Main Page when it scans the Main Page and, presumably, increases the rank of any indexable WP page linked from it.

Then again, if you're a POV pusher and you're trying to increase your article's visibility, I'd assume you'll want to make sure you've got the content under control and properly protected from the opposition before you start "advertising" it in the form of DYK's and so on. Otherwise you risk increased article-molestation... OTOH, these DYK's only stay up for a few hours, apparently - not even a full day. I guess that's usually enough for an increase in Google-juice, but probably not enough to increase your molestation-risk factor.
A Horse With No Name
QUOTE(Somey @ Tue 19th May 2009, 12:18pm) *

QUOTE(A Horse With No Name @ Tue 19th May 2009, 7:57am) *
...DYK award templates are 10 times the size of an FA icon but carry ten times less value?

That depends on what constitutes "value," doesn't it? AFAIK, Google doesn't differentiate much between a DYK link and the FA link from the Main Page when it scans the Main Page and, presumably, increases the rank of any indexable WP page linked from it.

Then again, if you're a POV pusher and you're trying to increase your article's visibility, I'd assume you'll want to make sure you've got the content under control and properly protected from the opposition before you start "advertising" it in the form of DYK's and so on. Otherwise you risk increased article-molestation... OTOH, these DYK's only stay up for a few hours, apparently - not even a full day. I guess that's usually enough for an increase in Google-juice, but probably not enough to increase your molestation-risk factor.


Mmmm, I like that expression "Google-juice"
Cock-up-over-conspiracy
Before I receive the offer of a one way ticket and an invitation to stay in Mordechai Vanunu's old apartment, I just wanted to crosslink this thread to the other documenting David Shankbone (T-C-L-K-R-D) 's Zionist backhander for his future services ensuring fair and objective editing about Israel on the Wikipedia such as pissing goats and loaded pictures of Palestinian kids playing with toy guns.
QUOTE
Image:Palestinian boy with toy guy in Nazareth by David Shankbone.jpg‎.

A recent study by Herzog’s trauma centre found that 33 per cent of Israeli youth have been affected personally by terrorism, either by being at the scene of an attack or by knowing someone injured or killed by terrorists. Seventy per cent of those surveyed reported increased subjective fear or hopelessness.




Mr Vanunu has converted to Christianity, see below.

I have been looking into this, and whilst the Israeli Ministry of the Interior continues to deny individuals their basic human rights (and Vanunu is forbidden to talk to foreigners or leave Israel), The Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs invited and presumably p-a-y-s for leading Wikipedian David 'Shankbone' Miller to come to Israel from Manhattan, go to gay nightclubs, and take pictures of pissing goats and what looking suspicious like incontinence pants for dribbly old Jews.

These were taken in March 2009. Does that mean he has been twice and on expenses?

Excuse me if this is old news for some of you or if I appear confused by the apparent contradiction in human values.
Image
Do you piss your pants? David has the answer for you!

See; the Right to Enter website.

QUOTE
1st May 2008 ISRAELIS DENY OFFICIAL CANNES FESTIVAL FILMMAKER ENTRY TO PALESTINE

Officially selected for the 2008 Cannes Film Festival, Palestinian filmmaker Annemarie Jacir has been denied entry to Palestine ... She was on her way home for the world premiere of her new film, Salt of this Sea. The first feature film by a Palestinian female director. She was held at the border for six hours, repeatedly questioned, her telephone taken from her, and then denied entry. Two agents from the Israeli Ministry of Interior escorted Annemarie from the terminal and placed her on a bus back to Jordan.

Israel continues to deny hundreds of people entry to Palestine. Annemarie, who is from the West Bank, has not been allowed into Palestine for nine months, which meant the some of the final scenes of her film could not be shot in Palestine.

QUOTE
In 2007, Israel "blocked clergy from reaching their churches and Christmas celebrations in Bethlehem and elsewhere in the Holy Land

The Israeli authorities are arbitrarily denying entry to clergy and volunteers belonging to or working for Christian institutions and service providers.

The clergy being harassed and denied entry to Israel and the occupied Palestinian territory join tens of thousands of ordinary foreign passport holders of Palestinian and non-Palestinian origin who wish to be with their families, work or study, as well as tourists and pilgrims ... there appears to be a new policy by Israel to refuse entry or visa extension for foreign, primarily Western, Christian volunteers working with various Christian organizations.
Meringue
.
GlassBeadGame
QUOTE(Cock-up-over-conspiracy @ Sat 23rd May 2009, 4:39am) *

Before I receive the offer of a one way ticket and an invitation to stay in Mordechai Vanunu's old apartment, I just wanted to crosslink this thread to the other documenting David Shankbone (T-C-L-K-R-D) 's Zionist backhander for his future services ensuring fair and objective editing about Israel on the Wikipedia such as pissing goats and loaded pictures of Palestinian kids playing with toy guns.
QUOTE
Image:Palestinian boy with toy guy in Nazareth by David Shankbone.jpg‎.

A recent study by Herzog’s trauma centre found that 33 per cent of Israeli youth have been affected personally by terrorism, either by being at the scene of an attack or by knowing someone injured or killed by terrorists. Seventy per cent of those surveyed reported increased subjective fear or hopelessness.




Mr Vanunu has converted to Christianity, see below.

I have been looking into this, and whilst the Israeli Ministry of the Interior continues to deny individuals their basic human rights (and Vanunu is forbidden to talk to foreigners or leave Israel), The Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs invited and presumably p-a-y-s for leading Wikipedian David 'Shankbone' Miller to come to Israel from Manhattan, go to gay nightclubs, and take pictures of pissing goats and what looking suspicious like incontinence pants for dribbly old Jews.

These were taken in March 2009. Does that mean he has been twice and on expenses?

Excuse me if this is old news for some of you or if I appear confused by the apparent contradiction in human values.
Image
Do you piss your pants? David has the answer for you!

See; the Right to Enter website.

QUOTE
1st May 2008 ISRAELIS DENY OFFICIAL CANNES FESTIVAL FILMMAKER ENTRY TO PALESTINE

Officially selected for the 2008 Cannes Film Festival, Palestinian filmmaker Annemarie Jacir has been denied entry to Palestine ... She was on her way home for the world premiere of her new film, Salt of this Sea. The first feature film by a Palestinian female director. She was held at the border for six hours, repeatedly questioned, her telephone taken from her, and then denied entry. Two agents from the Israeli Ministry of Interior escorted Annemarie from the terminal and placed her on a bus back to Jordan.

Israel continues to deny hundreds of people entry to Palestine. Annemarie, who is from the West Bank, has not been allowed into Palestine for nine months, which meant the some of the final scenes of her film could not be shot in Palestine.

QUOTE
In 2007, Israel "blocked clergy from reaching their churches and Christmas celebrations in Bethlehem and elsewhere in the Holy Land

The Israeli authorities are arbitrarily denying entry to clergy and volunteers belonging to or working for Christian institutions and service providers.

The clergy being harassed and denied entry to Israel and the occupied Palestinian territory join tens of thousands of ordinary foreign passport holders of Palestinian and non-Palestinian origin who wish to be with their families, work or study, as well as tourists and pilgrims ... there appears to be a new policy by Israel to refuse entry or visa extension for foreign, primarily Western, Christian volunteers working with various Christian organizations.



I have previously called attention to the Palestinian child with a gun picture, calling it dehumanizing, exploitative and racist. I have no doubt that Israel engages in endless repressive measures against people under it's military control, both her own citizens and those under the control of "Bantustan" aparthide states often too weak to protect their own people. This repression also doubtlessly extends to travelers and visitors from other countries. For all that we might agree on I can't abide your "dribbly old Jews" comment. This might be a small thing given the over all context, still it seems anti-Semitic and hateful. For some people "Anti-Zionist but not Anti-Semitic" is more than a set piece of rhetoric.
Jon Awbrey
I agree with GPS — some of this stuff belongs in the Tarpit or even deleted. The thread as a whole has taken the kind of turn that puts it more in Politics, Religion, & Suck than in General Discussion of social media.

Jon sick.gif Image
sbrown
Yep we are here to discus wikipeida not world politics. Shankbone is fair game because hes a great example of how rotten the wikipeida mafia is not because he holds this or that political view that is held by lots of respectable people even if you or I disagree with it.
Cock-up-over-conspiracy
QUOTE(GlassBeadGame @ Sat 23rd May 2009, 1:55pm) *
For all that we might agree on I can't abide your "dribbly old Jews" comment. This might be a small thing given the over all context, still it seems anti-Semitic and hateful.

Shoot the messenger to distract from the message, huh?

Who is mocking who at whose expense? Who is essentially making a joke out of incontinence pants and those they are being sold to? ... Not me, my friend. I or an admin can edit to whatever suits you but, please, skip ridiculous notions like that.

All I am referencing is that context. The picture was taken on a government sponsored PR jaunt organized, and we presume paid for, by the Israeli government to effect Wiki content. If there is anyone who should be offended, it is the Israeli tax payers at the individuals who carried this out.

As I have answered in the other topic, this is about the Wikipedia. This is very seriously about the wikipedia. Here you have on one hand the Israeli Foreign Ministry, on the other hand a group like Camera.org ... working to similar goals.

Personally, I have had 0% involvement with middle eastern politics and 0% involvement with middle eastern topics. All I am interested in is demonstrating the culture of the Wikipedia and here you a few red hot ethical issues which, as far as I am aware, is going on without any discussion at all on the official website.

This first of which are ...

a) how do the trustees feel about the "good standing" of the Wikipedia being used for person benefit in this way, were they aware?
b) what safeguards are they taking to protect the neutrality of the Wikipedia?
c) is there a policy on accepting such gigs or professional standards in taking them?

If it had been Ireland, it would have been Irish ... Bolivia, Bolivian. It has nothing to do with race. May be you ought to listen to some more Jewish comedians. It is the ugliness of the facts that are offensive and it is those that you should be concerned about. Its strange but, to date ... no one has.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.