Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Wikipedia ordered by judge to break confidentiality of contributor
> Media Forums > News Worth Discussing
A User
"A senior judge has ordered Wikipedia, the online encyclopedia, to disclose the identity of one of its contributors after a mother and her young child pleaded for help in identifying an alleged blackmailer.

In the first case of its kind, Mr Justice Tugendhat ordered Wikipedia’s parent company, Florida-based Wikimedia Foundation Inc, to disclose the computer identity, known as an IP address, of one of its registered users.

The judge acted after hearing that the mother, who is well known in the business world, had received anonymous letters threatening to disclose to the media details of her professional life and expenses.

The mystery Wikipedia user made an “amendment” to the mother’s entry, also referring to her young child, and disclosing confidential and “sensitive” information about them. The businesswoman believes the Wikipedia contributor and the author of the anonymous letters are the same person."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/wiki...ontributor.html
carbuncle
QUOTE(WikiWatch @ Wed 2nd December 2009, 6:40pm) *

In the first case of its kind, Mr Justice Tugendhat ordered Wikipedia’s parent company, Florida-based Wikimedia Foundation Inc, to disclose the computer identity, known as an IP address, of one of its registered users.

Surely this can't be "the first case of its kind"?
QUOTE
Wikimedia, while stressing it had nothing to do with the amendment, said it would disclose the IP address – but only if ordered to do so - effectively breaching the confidentiality of the contributor. Mr Justice Tugendhat has done just that to try to help the businesswoman track down the amendment writer even though they may have already covered their cyber-tracks.

Mr Justice Tugendhat is a British High Court justice, so this likely has no bearing whatsoever on the WMF's actions.
Kelly Martin
QUOTE(carbuncle @ Wed 2nd December 2009, 1:41pm) *
QUOTE(WikiWatch @ Wed 2nd December 2009, 6:40pm) *
In the first case of its kind, Mr Justice Tugendhat ordered Wikipedia’s parent company, Florida-based Wikimedia Foundation Inc, to disclose the computer identity, known as an IP address, of one of its registered users.
Surely this can't be "the first case of its kind"?
It's not. Not even close. The only remotely unusual aspect is that the names of all the parties are being kept confidential. The only remotely interesting thing that could come of this would be if the Foundation (which cannot be bound by any order of secrecy imposed by the British court, since that court lacks jurisdiction over the Foundation) chose to publish the order, which almost certainly include sufficient information to identify the parties to the case.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.