"Hey," I feel that now is the time for every good Wikipedia Reviewer to
flood the comments.
Since it's probably headed for the "Report abuse" file, I'd better copy it here:
QUOTE
thekohser
12/15/2009 8:40:23 PM
I find it ironic (or, is it "hypocritical") that Craig Newmark is a vocal champion of transparency in government, but then he goes on and on here and elsewhere about his support of a Wikimedia Foundation that is utterly lacking in transparency or ethics in its governance. The "co-founder" of Wikipedia insists that everyone call him "The Founder", and they all obey. The Foundation said it would need $2.6 million for technology in 2008, but they only spent $900K of it, stuffing the remainder in the bank. The Foundation was still shuttling rent money to Wikia, Inc. (the company that once employed 60% of the WMF board) as recently as this summer. The Deputy Director was hired straight off the board of trustees, without a job description, much less a candidate search -- in so doing, they employed someone with a history of defending child pornography as "doing no harm", as long as it's non-violent. The former Chief Operating Officer was a multi-count felon, wanted in two states. And when Jimbo Wales was accused of submitting for reimbursement receipts for pricy steakhouse tabs and a Moscow massage parlor, the Executive Director's response was to say -- on camera, on CNET -- that "Jimmy has never done anything wrong".
(None of my comments are personal attacks. These lapses in ethical governance have all been reported in the tech media.)
The independent Charity Navigator organization rates the WMF as 2 stars (out of four) in organizational efficiency. Their audit, not mine (though I would have given only 1 star, given that a partner in the firm that has money invested in the WMF co-founder's for-profit commercial enterprise, recently bought HIMSELF a board seat).
I'm not sure I could find a more comic notion than the thought of giving money to the Wikimedia Foundation. It is wholly off-track from what you would expect of a dutiful body entrusted with knowledge management. It's a complete mess.