Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Did You Know?
> Wikimedia Discussion > Articles
JohnA
From today's DYK

Image

What does the article say?

QUOTE
Built in ashlar stone, the building is roofless.[3]


English Heritage says:

QUOTE
Parish church, now redundant and roofless.


What does Google Earth show?

Image

Strange....

carbuncle
Who you gonna believe - WP or your lying eyes?
thekohser
Obviously, when the church heard that the Google satellite would be flying overhead, they hired this guy to chalk their roofless church floor, so that it looks like it has a roof. For insurance purposes, of course.
Michaeldsuarez
http://www.visitchurches.org.uk/AboutCCTou...s/2000Hartwell/

They decided to re-roof the church in 2000.

Edit: Credit for finding the source goes to the anon on Talk:St_Mary's_Church,_Hartwell.
lilburne
Away with you all: Wikipedia is NOTTRUTH.
Kelly Martin
Using Google Earth to determine that the church does, in fact, have a roof is prohibited original research. If sources say the church has no roof, then it has no roof, and any evidence to the contrary that hasn't been published on the Internet must simply be disregarded as unreliable.
A Horse With No Name
They should really change the name of that category from "Did You Know?" to "Do You Really Care?" ermm.gif
Cock-up-over-conspiracy
QUOTE(Kelly Martin @ Mon 9th May 2011, 6:50pm) *
Using Google Earth to determine that the church does, in fact, have a roof is prohibited original research.

That is a strange one I came up against recently, "It is not proof enough to read a picture, you have to read someone else saying what is in the picture."

Why aren't pictures reliable sources?

"If a picture paints a thousands words ...", sung by Vin Diesel's father ...
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.