I share your sense of shock and dismay. The figure would appear to be a most appropriate representation of the ideals of the WMF; all set to "repel trolls and stalkers" with her Crosier of Power.
This is Wikipedia. You let Deviant Art nerds edit an "encyclopedia", and they will inevitably turn Commons into another Deviant Art. And then fill it up with their insipid fetishistic manga-pinup art.
(Don't forget, Niabot also did this one. NSFW. Niabot tries to nominate all of his cartoons for Featured Pictures, and very few of them get thru. Read the Futanari talkpage for more fun.)
carbuncle
QUOTE(EricBarbour @ Mon 16th May 2011, 8:36pm)
This is Wikipedia. You let Deviant Art nerds edit an "encyclopedia", and they will inevitably turn Commons into another Deviant Art. And then fill it up with their insipid fetishistic manga-pinup art.
(Don't forget, Niabot also did this one. NSFW. Niabot tries to nominate all of his cartoons for Featured Pictures, and very few of them get thru. Read the Futanari talkpage for more fun.)
Looks like someone on Foundation-L made the connection:
QUOTE
Dan Rosenthal swatjester at gmail.com Mon May 16 22:22:29 UTC 2011
I feel like this image from the same author: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Futanari.png might be crossing the lines. Given Niabot's user page loudly railing against Commons being "censored", I'd say the issue is less "art" and more "lets see who we can shock and/or piss off."
-Dan
Alison
QUOTE(EricBarbour @ Mon 16th May 2011, 1:36pm)
(Don't forget, Niabot also did this one. NSFW. Niabot tries to nominate all of his cartoons for Featured Pictures, and very few of them get thru. Read the Futanari talkpage for more fun.)
(Don't forget, Niabot also did this one. NSFW. Niabot tries to nominate all of his cartoons for Featured Pictures, and very few of them get thru. Read the Futanari talkpage for more fun.)
I'm not usually a fan of Niabots work, but I love the octopus in that one. I think it should replace Wikipetan as WP's official unofficial mascot. Septo, the seven-armed octopus.
I share your sense of shock and dismay. The figure would appear to be a most appropriate representation of the ideals of the WMF; all set to "repel trolls and stalkers" with her Crosier of Power.
There was quite a bit of discussion at the Russian Wikipedia's main page talk about the Edge of the World image when it appeared on their main page.
One of the Russian editors nominated the Edge of the World image for delisting as a featured picture, and got a well-argued, civil response, based on the other editor's superior understanding of Commons' educational mission.
I share your sense of shock and dismay. The figure would appear to be a most appropriate representation of the ideals of the WMF; all set to "repel trolls and stalkers" with her Crosier of Power.
There was quite a bit of discussion at the Russian Wikipedia's main page talk about the Edge of the World image when it appeared on their main page.
One of the Russian editors nominated the Edge of the World image for delisting as a featured picture, and got a well-argued, civil response, based on the other editor's superior understanding of Commons' educational mission.
Your arguments in the removal page were quite good. But it's not working--I count 7 to keep and 5 to delist. (Nerds do love those anime boobs. Takes one to know one. )
Your arguments in the removal page were quite good. But it's not working--I count 7 to keep and 5 to delist. (Nerds do love those anime boobs. Takes one to know one. )
That's a valid point. Any picture with boobs is automatically considered valuable and educational by at least a third of voters, without further considerations coming into play. So it's an up-boob struggle.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.