Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Very sneaky censorship on Foundation-l
> Wikimedia Discussion > Bureaucracy
thekohser
We already know that Austin Hair and his gang of over-zealous moderator-thugs have taken over the Foundation-l mailing list by banning and moderating any voices that dare challenge the established happy group-think.

However, this is really rather mind-boggling:

Isn't this a rather unusual post by Mike Dupont?

Oh, wait -- it was copied back in a reply post.

But it's not at all the same message between the original and the copy. Has the Foundation really stooped so far as to censor mailing list posts in the archives, even after they've been released to the list?

(Edit: Nope, they just run a piece of software that is so stupid, it deletes any message that begins with a sentence that sets forth with the word "From". So, Dupont's post was removed, although it could be copied back by others.)
MZMcBride
There's a bug in the archive software. True story.

At least it's consistently broken? (The text of the message in question can be found here [scroll down].)

And FWIW, there are other archives that suck a little less than (or maybe equal to) mailman's pipermail. Or at least there are other archives that don't get tripped up by "From" at the beginning of a line. They're scattered about the Web. If you google part of a mailing list post, you should be able to find a few.
thekohser
That has to be one of the funniest things ever. I don't know what would be worse -- a non-profit mailing list moderator who censors the web archives if they contain content by or about an enemy of the WikiState; or, a mailing list archive function that automatically deletes content if a sentence begins with the word "From"!
lilburne
QUOTE(thekohser @ Sun 24th July 2011, 3:30am) *

That has to be one of the funniest things ever. I don't know what would be worse -- a non-profit mailing list moderator who censors the web archives if they contain content by or about an enemy of the WikiState; or, a mailing list archive function that automatically deletes content if a sentence begins with the word "From"!


Problem first reported 7 years ago. It seems to be a perfect match for wikipedia as neither product are under any deadline to get error fixed.

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.